Part of the reason I like Doris Chan's patterns is that they are worked top down in one piece. The first time I saw a knitting/crochet pattern with this type of design it was an epiphany. Most designs are planned out like sewing patterns: a left front, right front, back and sleeves. This concept works when turning two dimensional fabric into a three dimensional garment. Knitting and Crocheting are inherently sculptural and treating them as only a means to make fabric for sewing patterns is to minimize their potential. Top down construction lets the garment grow organically which gives you a freedom and control that you don't have with the sewing pattern scheme. It also eliminates seam sewing so when the Knitting/Crocheting is finished the piece is basically finished. For impatient needleworkers like me, that's a big plus.
There is a flexibility to this type of construction that allows changes and corrections as you work. With Chloe this came in handy. When I got to the portion of the pattern where the front and back were differentiated by joining and creating the underarm, I ran into a problem. No matter what I did my stitch count was off. Up until that point the count was perfect. Spot on! At the join it went wrong. I ripped it back and recrocheted it three or four times and each time I was off. In desperation I went on Ravelry. I assumed that I had screwed up at first but after counting, recounting and still ending up with an error I began to suspect it wasn't me. I posted a plea for help on the Everyday Crochet group and the Interweave Crochet group. No one responded. I was frustrated. The temptation to just power through was intense. I was worried that if I didn't figure out the mistake I would compound it if I just kept going.
So I put Chloe down and started on Cinnabar. This is a very nice, simple pattern from Everyday Crochet and I'm making it in Naturally Caron Country in Peacock. But I had plans for Chloe.
I was going to a convention at the end of April and wanted to wear Chloe. It would be the perfect jacket: light enough to wear indoors but heavy enough to keep off the chill of the AC in the conference room and, like most of Doris' patterns, you can dress it up or down. I would only have to pack the one cardigan.
Having no better idea, I did what any thwarted crocheter would do: I pestered the designer. Isn't Ravelry great? Ms. Chan was wonderfully helpful. After apologizing profusely for bugging her personally I explained where I had gotten lost on Chloe. Neither of us could figure out what had gone wrong. In the time between my posting to the groups about the stitch count issues and hearing back from Ms. Chan I received several Ravelry messages from other crocheters who had the same problem I did. Doris gave me her blessing to just power through. She said that as long as the stitch pattern was lining up properly I could fudge it and have it all still work out. I took a deep breath and drove on.
She was right. After the underarm join I was two ch-3 spaces short of what the pattern called for but I just worked with that. It didn't become an issue until I got to the waistband. Once there I just eliminated two spaces and followed on from there.
Once the body was done I joined the yarn to the underarm and worked the sleeves without a problem.
It's lovely if I say so myself. I'm really happy with the finished product and I was smart enough to make notes on the pattern so I can make this again without bothering Doris. And most importantly:
it fits.